diff options
Diffstat (limited to 'docs/bug-mgmt/policies/regressions-github.rst')
-rw-r--r-- | docs/bug-mgmt/policies/regressions-github.rst | 151 |
1 files changed, 151 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/docs/bug-mgmt/policies/regressions-github.rst b/docs/bug-mgmt/policies/regressions-github.rst new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..1a3c6b2a4d --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/bug-mgmt/policies/regressions-github.rst @@ -0,0 +1,151 @@ +Regressions from GitHub +======================= + +Release Management and the weekly regression triage must be aware of the +status of all reported regressions in order to assure we are not +shipping known regressions in Firefox releases. + +If a team is using GitHub to manage their part of the Firefox project, +there’s a risk that those groups might not see a regression. + +We need an agreed to standard for how we keep track of these. + +Policy +------ + +*All Firefox components, even if their bugs are tracked off of Bugzilla, +must have a component in Bugzilla.* + +*If a regression bug is found in any of the release trains (Nightly, +Beta, Release, or ESR) and the bug is in a Firefox component which uses +an external repository, the regression must be tracked by a bug in +Bugzilla (whether or not the component in question uses an external +issue tracker).* + +*Unless approved by Release Management, any GitHub managed code with +open regressions will not be merged to mozilla-central. Even if the +regression is not code that has been previously merged into +mozilla-central.* + +*All Firefox code managed in GitHub which uses GitHub to manage +issues* `must use the shared +tags <https://mozilla.github.io/bmo-harmony/labels>`__. + +Comments +~~~~~~~~ + +The bug **must** have the regression keyword. + +The bug **must** have release flags set. + +If the team works in an external bug tracker, then the Bugzilla bug +**must** reference, using the see-also field, the URL of the bug in the +external tracker. + +The bug **must not** be RESOLVED until the code from the external +repository containing the change set for the bug has landed in +mozilla-central. When the change set lands in mozilla-central, the +Bugzilla tracking bug should be set to RESOLVED FIXED and release status +flags should be updated to reflect the release trains the fix has been +landed or uplifted into. + +If the change set containing the patch for the regression is reverted +from mozilla-central, for any reason, then the tracking bug for the +regression **must** be set to REOPENED and the release status flags +updated accordingly. + +If the change set containing the patch for the bug is backed out, for +any reason, the bug must be reopened and the status flags on the +Bugzilla tracking bug updated. + +The team responsible for the component with the regression **should** +strive to create a patch for mozilla-central which contains the fix for +the bug alone, not a monolithic patch containing changes for several +other bugs or features. + +Landings of third-party libraries `must contain a manifest +file <https://docs.google.com/document/d/12ihxPXBo9zBBaU_pBsPrc_wNHds4Upr-PwFfiSHrbu8>`__. + +Best Practices +-------------- + +You must file a regression bug in Bugzilla +~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ + +*If the code with the regression has landed in mozilla-central, you must +file a regression bug.* + +Example +^^^^^^^ + +While using a release of Firefox (Nightly, Beta, Release, ESR) you run +across a bug. Upon research using MozRegression or other tools you find +that the bug was introduced in a change set imported from a component +whose code and issues are managed in GitHub. + +Actions to take +''''''''''''''' + +- Open a new bug in Bugzilla in appropriate component and add the + REGRESSION keyword +- Set affected status for the releases where the bug appears +- Open an issue in the corresponding GitHub project, put the Bugzilla + bug number in the title with the prefix ‘Bug’ (i.e. “Bug 99999: + Regression in foo”) +- Add the REGRESSION label to the new issue +- Add the link to the GitHub issue into the ‘See Also” field in the + Bugzilla bug + +Consequences +'''''''''''' + +*Until the regression is fixed or backed out of the GitHub repo, the +project cannot merge code into mozilla-central* + +Example +^^^^^^^ + +You import a development branch of a component managed in GitHub into +your copy of master. You find a bug and isolate it to the imported +branch. The code is managed in their own GitHub project, but bugs are +managed in Bugzilla. + +Actions to take +''''''''''''''' + +- Open a new bug in Bugzilla in appropriate component and add the + REGRESSION keyword +- Set affected status for the releases where the bug appears + +Consequences +'''''''''''' + +*Until the regression is fixed or backed out of the GitHub repo, the +project cannot merge code into mozilla-central* + +Do not file a regression bug in Bugzilla +~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ + +*If the code with the regression has not landed in mozilla-central, you +do not need to file a bug.* + + +Example +^^^^^^^ + +You import a development branch of a component managed in GitHub into +your copy of master. You find a bug and isolate it to the imported +branch. The code and issues are managed in their own GitHub project. + + +Actions to take +''''''''''''''' + +- File new issue in the GitHub repository of the imported code. +- Label issue as REGRESSION + +Consequence +''''''''''' + +*Issue blocks merge of GitHub project with mozilla-central until +resolved or backed out.* |